In his pioneering sexual ethnography, the late Robert Stoller was always careful to qualify his perceptions with the acknowledgment of his own limitations as a perceiver. Under the circumstances, this reviewer can do no less. I was a participant in Stoller’s investigation of the lives and souls of those who make porn and am quoted in this book at some length under the pseudonym “Ron.” I went on to co-author a second book on the subject with Stoller, Coming Attractions, which was published just after his tragic death in an automobile accident.
Like most of his later work, Porn consists mainly of interviews—interlaced with the author’s questions and comments of the performers, directors, writers and associated hangers-on who make their livings cranking out sexually explicit videos. While carefully avoiding political or moral judgments, Stoller nonetheless paints a picture from a definite perspective. By dedicating so many pages to voluble porn industry spokesperson and self-styled moral iconoclast Bill Margold, Stoller makes his case for porn as a refuge of talented misfits and sexual nonconformists. As the author puts it, “The motivating sentiment of porn is less ‘Let’s fuck’ than ‘Fuck you.’” Certainly, by encouraging his informants to share their often-troubled personal histories, elicited with a master psychoanalyst’s seeming effortlessness, he gives plenty of reasons why porn people might be angry and rebellious. Abandonment, abuse and molestation are recurring themes in the narratives of performers and off-camera industry personalities alike. Even interviewees like Nina Hartley, who profess to enjoy their work and disdain the sympathies of those who regard them as exploited, have their share of resentments to unload at anti-porn feminists and younger performers.
Though Stoller’s investigations don’t contribute additional ammo to porn-bashers, they give little comfort to those who prefer to imagine sex work as an endless toga party. Much of the evidence Stoller educes seems to corroborate his much-misunderstood and widely castigated theorem that “the erotic imagination is energized by the element of harm.” It is the angry edge of porn and the people who make it that gives it its vitality. Porn is a tribute to the memory of a scientist who shunned easy polemics in favor of uncomfortable paradoxes.
IL
Publisher: Yale University
Hardback: 228 pages